Compare · as of November 2026
Tally vs Matomo
Matomo is open-source analytics you can host yourself or rent as Matomo Cloud, with ecommerce reports fed by an order call on your confirmation page. Tally reads each payment from your provider and shows, sale by sale, which visit brought the buyer.
14 days free, no card needed.
01In short
Choose Matomo for open source under the GPL, data on your own servers or in Frankfurt, a Google Analytics import and a wide set of plugins: heatmaps, A/B testing, form analytics, six attribution models. Choose Tally when the question is which visits made money: it reads Stripe, Paddle, Polar, WooCommerce and Squarespace directly, Shopify through its app and any other provider through its Payments API, with the renewals and refunds that arrive long after the visit, and a receipt for every link.
02Side by side
| Matomo | Tally | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Cloud is priced by hits a month (pageviews, events, downloads, outlinks and site searches) in tiers from 50,000, by quote past 10 million, before tax, with two months free on yearly billing. On-Premise is free to host yourself; plugin bundles start from €230 a month. [1] | From $9 a month for 10k events, with every site and every feature on every step; a year costs 9 months. |
| Trial | 21 days free on Cloud, no credit card. Of the paid On-Premise bundles, only Team has a free trial. [2][1] | 14 days free, no card needed. |
| Websites | Cloud's Business plan includes 30 websites and 30 team members; Enterprise limits are custom. [1] | Every site on every plan; the price follows the events across all of them. |
| How revenue gets in | Your site's code tracks each order with trackEcommerceOrder, typically on the order confirmation page once payment is confirmed, with the order id, grand total, tax, shipping and discount. [3] | Read from Stripe, Paddle, Polar, WooCommerce or Squarespace once connected, or from a Shopify store through Tally's app, refunds included, and renewals and chargebacks where the provider reports them. The amounts come from the provider, not your pages; other providers' payments, your server posts to the Payments API. |
| Stores and payment providers | Its integrations page lists Shopify (through custom pixels), PrestaShop and BigCommerce among ecommerce platforms. We didn't find Stripe, Paddle or Polar on it (November 2026). [4] | WooCommerce and Squarespace connect in one click and Shopify through Tally's app, and the page a buyer lands on after checkout links the order to its visit. |
| Attribution | Conversions go to the last non-direct visit by default, or to the first referrer with one line in the tracking code; the Multi Channel Conversion Attribution plugin adds six models. [5][6] | A sale is credited to the buyer's last visit that didn't come direct; their first visit is recorded too, and both are on the sale's receipt. |
| Cookies and consent | It can be set up to set no cookies and collect no personal data; whether a banner is still needed depends on the country, and Matomo recommends treating JavaScript tracking as needing consent until a regulator says otherwise. [7] | Per site: cookieless, one first-party cookie for returning visitors, or cookieless until your banner says yes. |
| Where data lives | Cloud data is stored in Frankfurt, Germany; On-Premise, on the servers you choose. [1] | Stored on servers we rent and run in the United States. |
| Open source | Released under the GNU General Public License v3.0 or later; On-Premise is free to download and host yourself. [8][9] | Hosted only, not open source. |
| Heatmaps and recordings | Heatmaps and session recordings on Matomo Cloud; on On-Premise, in the paid Team bundle and up, or as a premium plugin bought on its own. [2][1] | Session replay and heatmaps on every step, off until you turn them on, with every input masked. |
| AI assistants | An AI Assistants report among the core reports every bundle includes, the free Community edition too. [1] | A channel for visitors from AI assistants, and AI crawlers counted apart from visitors. |
| Importing history | The Google Analytics Importer plugin, a free download, imports your Google Analytics properties. [10] | No import of other analytics; payments come in from 365 days back. |
| Retention and sampling | Cloud's Business plan keeps raw data for 24 months and reports forever, with no data sampling. [1] | Nothing is sampled, and what was recorded stays in your account while you have it. |
03Where Matomo is better
- Open source under the GPL, free to download and run on your own servers, so the data stays in your hands. [8][9]
- Matomo Cloud keeps its data in Frankfurt, Germany. [1]
- A 21-day Cloud trial with no card, a week longer than Tally's. [2]
- It imports your Google Analytics history with a free plugin. [10]
- Six attribution models for goals and ecommerce orders, through its Multi Channel Conversion Attribution plugin. [6]
- A/B testing, form analytics, cohorts and a tag manager among its plugins and Cloud features. [1]
04What Tally does differently
- Revenue comes from your payment provider, not from a call on the confirmation page, so a renewal months later, a refund or a sale paid with the tab closed still counts against the visit that won the customer.
- Every sale has a receipt: the visits behind it, what tied the payment to that browser, the method and how sure it is. A sale nothing links says so.
- Coverage shows the share of your revenue linked to a visitor, each reason the rest isn't, and the code that fixes it.
- Path to purchase and lifetime value by first source, built from the payments themselves.
- One plan with every site and every feature, priced by events alone, with nothing to host or update.
05Switching from Matomo
- Add Tally's tag to the head of every page beside Matomo's while you compare, then connect your payment provider: its past 365 days of payments come in.
- The trackEcommerceOrder call on your confirmation page isn't needed by Tally, which reads the payment itself; it can stay while Matomo does.
06Questions
Can I host Tally on my own servers, like Matomo?
No. Tally is hosted only. If keeping the software and the data on your own servers matters most, Matomo On-Premise is the better fit.
Does Tally need an order call on my confirmation page?
Not to count revenue: each payment is read from your provider, refunds included. To tie it to a visit, Tally uses the visitor's id in checkout metadata, the page the buyer lands on after paying, or their email, and the Coverage page shows what to add for sales that aren't linked yet.
Can Tally run without cookies?
Yes. Cookieless mode sets no cookie and counts a visitor once a day; consent-first mode stays cookieless until your banner says yes, then adds one first-party cookie.
07Sources
Each statement about Matomo comes from Matomo's own pages, read on November 18, 2026. Products change: check theirs before you decide.
- Matomo pricingmatomo.org
- Matomo Cloudmatomo.org
- Matomo FAQ: manually tracking ecommerce actionsmatomo.org
- Matomo integrationsmatomo.org
- Matomo FAQ: how conversions are attributedmatomo.org
- Matomo Marketplace: Multi Channel Conversion Attributionplugins.matomo.org
- Matomo FAQ: analytics without consent or a cookie bannermatomo.org
- Matomo licencesmatomo.org
- Matomo On-Premisematomo.org
- Matomo Marketplace: Google Analytics Importerplugins.matomo.org